Learning from Ng

In the introduction to the Best American Short Stories 2025 annual, Celeste Ng writes about skipping reading the introductions when she’s read the anthology in the past. Even more interesting, she describes the criteria for good fiction she discovered in the process of making her selections. These criteria can be aspirational; they might be expectations we set for ourselves. Excerpts are below. I’ve added numbers and altered paragraphing.

[1] First and foremost, the story had to grab me. Sometimes this meant an unforgettable premise, or a propulsive plot, or characters so fully drawn that I felt I would know them if I met them on the street. Sometimes it was charm, or humor, or an unexpected twist. The stories that ended up in the Yes pile were ones I couldn’t get out of my head, that I kept thinking about days or even weeks after reading them.

[2] Second, the story had to feel complete…. I wanted a sense that the writer had considered the story holistically, that every choice had been made deliberately, and that all the pieces fit together, even if the… [whole] picture wasn’t fully revealed. And by the time I reached the last line, I needed to understand something more about the situation than I did at the start…

[3] Third, the language of this story had to be of the very highest caliber. If a piece didn’t have sentences that startled or surprised me, or images that took my breath away with their absolute rightness, they usually didn’t make the cut….

[4] And finally … stories had to have heft … They didn’t have to be serious or sad… But I had to feel that this story and these characters were deeply important to the author, not just a thought experiment or a whim…. I also tend to gravitate towards stories that are in conversation with big topics, whether that means our current moment or broad-reaching and eternal themes…. The very best stories engage with more than just the purely personal, and this is what turns a good story into a great story.

Reading 2025

TitleAuthorDate Read
The West PassageJared Pechaček2025/12/22
Inherent ViceThomas Pynchon2025/12/19
Under the Eye of the Big BirdHiromi Kawakami2025/11/29
Emily Wilde’s Compendium of Lost Tales (Emily Wilde, #3)Heather Fawcett2025/11/27
Tuesday Mooney Talks to GhostsKate Racculia2025/11/16
The Wood at MidwinterSusanna Clarke2025/10/27
Swamplandia!Karen Russell2025/10/26
Wild Dark ShoreCharlotte McConaghy2025/10/17
Tooth and Claw (A Longmire Mystery, #0.5)Craig Johnson2025/10/07
The Practice of Creative Writings: A Guide for StudentsHeather Sellers2022/06/28
The Tainted Cup (Shadow of the Leviathan, #1)Robert Jackson Bennett2025/10/02
HeadshotRita Bullwinkel2025/09/27
Emily Wilde’s Map of the Otherlands (Emily Wilde, #2)Heather Fawcett2025/09/22
Swords and Deviltry (Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser, #1)Fritz Leiber2025/09/15
Coriolis – The Third HorizonTomas Härenstam2025/09/13
Someone You Can Build a Nest InJohn Wiswell2025/09/12
The Baltimore Book of the DeadMarion Winik2025/08/25
Remember You Will DieEden  Robins2025/08/20
JackMarilynne Robinson2025/08/14
The Paper Magician (The Paper Magician #1)Charlie N. Holmberg2025/07/26
The Murder of Mr. Wickham (Mr. Darcy & Miss Tilney, #1)Claudia Gray2025/07/20
Love Your Enemies: How Decent People Can Save America from the Culture of ContemptArthur C. Brooks2025/07/17
The Rose Metal Press Field Guide to Writing Flash NonfictionDinty W. Moore2025/07/15
Tenth of DecemberGeorge Saunders2025/07/05
At the Mouth of the River of Bees: StoriesKij Johnson2025/06/30
Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone (Ernest Cunningham, #1)Benjamin   Stevenson2025/06/19
A Wizard of Earthsea (Earthsea Cycle, #1)Ursula K. Le Guin2025/06/09
The Great GatsbyF. Scott Fitzgerald2025/05/28
The Department of Truth, Vol 1: The End of the WorldJames Tynion IV2025/05/17
Bone: The Complete EditionJeff Smith2025/05/12
Black Woods Blue SkyEowyn Ivey2025/05/08
The Wonderful Wizard of Oz (Oz, #1)L. Frank Baum2025/04/29
City of Dancing GargoylesTara Campbell2025/04/20
The Daughter of Doctor MoreauSilvia Moreno-Garcia2025/04/19
Nine GoblinsT. Kingfisher2025/04/05
Truth Is the Arrow, Mercy Is the Bow: A DIY Manual for the Construction of StoriesSteve Almond2025/04/04
The Very Secret Society of Irregular WitchesSangu Mandanna2025/04/01
Squirrel Meets World (The Unbeatable Squirrel Girl, #1)Shannon Hale2025/03/27
White Trash Warlock (Adam Binder, #1)David R. Slayton2025/03/21
The Sparrow (The Sparrow, #1)Mary Doria Russell2025/03/13
The Scandalous Confessions of Lydia Bennet, WitchMelinda Taub2025/03/13
The Dream-Quest of Vellitt BoeKij Johnson2025/02/24
The God of the WoodsLiz    Moore2025/02/19
Pride and PrejudiceJane Austen2025/02/12
When the Women Come Out to DanceElmore Leonard2023/09/09
Hyperion (Hyperion Cantos, #1)Dan Simmons2025/02/01
The LibrarianistPatrick deWitt2025/01/27
2312Kim Stanley Robinson2025/01/11
The Last Emperox (The Interdependency, #3)John Scalzi2025/01/03

Learning from eavesdropping

Paraphrasing the hosts of the podcast Writing Excuses, someplace in season 19: When I say a narrative needs risk, it almost always needs a relationship. How does the failure affect the community around the character? People feel tension about things they can relate to, especially about things they can relate to being taken away from characters.

Learning from Bullwinkel

Consider this sentence from Headshot by Rita Bullwinkel:

Artemis Victor has no idea what it takes to own a house, but she knows what it takes to beat other people, which is what owning property seems like, beating other people at owning a piece of the earth and making that piece of earth yours, not to be shared with other people, because the owning of the property is a product of your victory over other humans, as in, you won more dollars than them so now this slice of land is yours for keeps.

Artemis is one of the young women boxers in Bullwinkel’s novel. This one-sentence summary of her appears early in one of the sections of the book in which she boxes. The novel is organized like a March Madness bracket, with each pairing of characters having a winner that moves on to the next pairing until finally the two characters most likely to win box each other. One thing to learn from Bullwinkel is the value of a clear organizational structure for a novel, especially one with many characters.

The sentence above is its own paragraph. It stands out on the page. It also reveals key elements of one character, specifically. It suggests what she does not know and how she thinks about the world. This is stated directly and succinctly. As readers learn more about the character, such as her feelings about her sisters, for example, Artemis becomes more rounded. So, one technique for writing a round character is a concise, memorable sentence juxtaposed with contrasting scenes. The sharper the contrast between the scenes and summary, the more sides the character will seem to have and the better readers will get to know them.

Learning from Crozier

Lorna Crozier’s prose poem “Vituperative” is an excellent example of several techniques. It also effectively models a structure. The title tells readers the name of the poem, and the body shows the title. This showing includes images driven by sensory language, synonyms, and examples. Poetic strategies include alliteration. Rather than the happy ending readers might be trained to expect, consistent with its title, the prose poem doubles down on its bitterness.

Simple and powerful.

Humanity in its infinite variety

Now, as the present crumbles away into a future that evolves more quickly than most of us can track, it seems impossible to write about contemporary life without writing science fiction. But the secret to doing it well doesn’t lie in suspenseful chase scenes, weighty messages, or mind-blowing existential puzzles. That stuff can be fun, but it can also feel pretty thin without something that’s supposed to be a specialty of literary novelists: the fullest appreciation of humanity in its infinite variety and intricacy. Do justice to that, and the wonders will take care of themselves. 

Laura Miller

Joyful outpouring

The goal of writing should be to produce something that feels like a spontaneous joyful outpouring but that is, on closer inspection, too finely made to be (merely) that—the story as fossil evidence of a deep process of exploration that, in our reading experience of it, is as fast and natural as a pop song.

George Saunders